|
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
BOI MINUTES JANUARY 14, 2009 |
|
| |
|
| |
BOARD OF INVESTMENTS MINUTES 1-14-09
PRESENT
- William R. Pryor, Chair
- Simon S. Russin, Vice Chair
- Herman Santos, Secretary
- Diane Sandoval
- Mark J. Saladino
- Michael Schneider
- Robert L. Spare
- Leonard Unger
ABSENT
STAFF, ADVISORS, PARTICIPANTS
- Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive Officer
- Robert Hill, Assistant Executive Officer
- Janice Golden, Assistant Executive Officer
- Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer
- John McClelland, CRE, Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate
- Vache Mahseredjian, CFA, Principal Investment Officer
- Christopher J. Wagner, Senior Investment Officer, Private Equity
- June Kim, Senior Investment Officer, Equities
- Trina Sanders, Investment Officer, Real Estate
- Robert Z. Santos, Investment Officer, Fixed Income
- Gerald Flintoft, Investment Officer, Private Equity
- Stuart Mesnik, Senior Investment Analyst
- Shelly P. Tilaye, Senior Investment Analyst, Private Equity
- Dale Johnson, Senior Investment Analyst, Equities
- David L. Muir, Chief Counsel
- Earl W. Buehner, Senior Staff Counsel
- Milliman Consultants
- Karen I. Steffen, FSA, EA, MAAA, Consulting Actuary
- Nick J. Collier, ASA, EA, MAAA, Consulting Actuary
- The Townsend Group
- - Institutional Real Estate Consultants
- Micolyn M. Yalonis, Principal
- Nakeyshia J. Kendall, Consultant
- ELECTION OF OFFICERS (Election of Chair, Vice Chair, Secretary,
and Audit Committee Member)
The gavel was turned over to Secretary
Santos to conduct the election of officers:
- Chair of the Board
Mr. Russin was nominated to the position of Chair of the Board
of Investments by Mr. Spare. Mr. Pryor was nominated to the position
of Chair of the Board of Investments by Mr. Saladino. Hearing no
other nominations the nominations were closed on a motion by Mr.
Saladino. A roll call vote was taken for the position of Chair
of the Board of Investments with the following results: Votes cast
for Mr. Russin: Mr. Russin, Mr. Schneider, Mr. Spare Votes cast
for Mr. Pryor:Mr. Unger, Ms. Sandoval. Mr. Saladino, Mr. Santos,
Mr. Pryor Secretary Santos announced that Mr. Pryor was elected
to the position of Chair of the Board of Investments.
- Vice Chair of the Board
Mr. Santos was nominated to the position of Vice Chair of the
Board of Investments by Mr. Pryor. Ms. Sandoval nominated Mr. Russin
to the position of Vice Chair of the Board of Investments. Mr.
Russin declined the nomination. Hearing no other nominations the
nominations were closed on a motion by Mr. Saladino. Mr. Santos
was elected to the position of Vice Chair of the Board of Investments.
- Secretary
of the Board
Mr. Russin nominated Ms. Sandoval to the position
of Secretary of the Board of Investments. Mr. Santos nominated
Mr. Schneider to the position of Secretary of the Board. Mr. Schneider
declined the nomination. Hearing no other nominations the nominations
were closed on a motion by Mr. Saladino. Ms. Sandoval was elected
to the position of Secretary of the Board of Investments.
- Audit Committee
Member
Mr. Schneider was nominated to the position of Audit Committee
member by Mr. Russin. Hearing no other nominations the nominations
were closed on a motion by Mr. Pryor. Mr. Schneider was elected
to the position of Audit Committee Member of the Board of Investments.
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING
OF NOVEMBER 19, 2008.
A motion was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by Mr. Saladino to
approve the Minutes of the regular meeting of the Board of Investments
of November 19, 2008. The motion carried with Ms. Sandoval abstaining.
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF DECEMBER
10, 2008.
A motion was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by Mr. Spare
to approve the Minutes of the regular meeting of the Board of Investments
of December 10, 2008. The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- PUBLIC COMMENT
None.
- REPORT ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
None.
- CONSENT AGENDA
The following agenda items were placed on the consent agenda and
unanimously approved upon a motion by Mr. Santos, seconded by Ms.
Sandoval.
- Recommendation as submitted by Stuart Mesnik, Senior
Investment Analyst: (1) Approve attendance of Board Members and/or
staff as designated by the Chief Executive Officer to attend
the Second Annual Corporate Governance Roundup to be held on
February 23, 2009, at the Sheraton Gateway Hotel at Los Angeles
Airport; and (2) Approve reimbursement of all applicable travel
costs associated with attendance at the conference in accordance
with LACERA's Travel and Education Policy. (Memo dated December
8, 2008.) (Placed on the Agenda at the request of Mr. Pryor.)
- Recommendation as submitted by John D. McClelland,
Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate: (1) Approve attendance
of Board members, and staff as designated by the Chief Executive
Officer, at the RREEF Client Conference 2009 on February 24-25,
2009, at the Balboa Bay Club, Newport Beach, California; and (2)
Approve reimbursement of all costs associated with Conference attendance
in accordance with LACERA's Education and Travel Policy. (Memo
dated January 5, 2009.)
- ACTION ITEMS
- Recommendation as submitted by John D. McClelland,
Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate: (1) Approve attendance
of Board members, and staff as designated by the Chief Executive
Officer, at the Institute for Fiduciary Education and seminar "Real Estate Investing - Spring 2009," in
Phoenix, Arizona; and (2) Approve reimbursement of all costs associated
with Conference attendance in accordance with LACERA's Education
and Travel Policy. (Memo dated January 6, 2009.) A motion to approve
the recommendation was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by Mr. Schneider.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Robert Z. Santos, Investment
Officer, Fixed Income: (1) Approve attendance of Board members,
and staff as designated by the Chief Executive Officer, at the
Information Management Network's (15th Annual Beneficial Owners'
International Securities Lending & Repo Summit to be held at the Hyatt Regency Scottsdale Resort & Spa
at Gainey Ranch in Scottsdale, Arizona; and (2) Approve reimbursement
of all costs associated with the Conference attendance in accordance
with LACERA's Education and Travel Policy. (Memo dated January
5, 2009.)
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr.
Santos, seconded by Mr. Spare. The motion carried by unanimous
vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by John D. McClelland,
Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate (1) Approve attendance
of Board members, and staff as designated by the Chief Executive
Officer, at the IREI VIP 2009 Conference, and approve reimbursement
of all travel costs incurred in accordance with LACERA's Education
and Travel Policy. (Memo dated December 29, 2008.)
A motion to
approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded by
Mr. Santos. The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Stuart Mesnik, Senior
Investment Analyst: (1) Approve attendance of Board members to
attend the Pacific Pension Institute's 2009 Winter Roundtable on
February 25-27, 2009, at The Lodge at Torrey Pines in La Jolla,
California; and (2) Approve reimbursement of all applicable travel
costs associated with attendance at the conference in accordance
with the Education and Travel Policy. (Memo dated January 8, 2009.)
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Saladino,
seconded by Mr. Spare. The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted
by John D. McClelland, Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate:
Adopt the NCREIF Property Index minus 25 basis points measured
over rolling five-year periods as the overall benchmark for the
real estate investment program effective January 1, 2009. (Memo
dated January 6, 2009.)
The Townsend Group Institutional Real Estate
Consultants
Micolyn M. Yalonis, Principal
Nakeyshia J. Kendall, Consultant
Mr. McClelland provided a brief overview on the proposed real
estate benchmark change and reported that if the new benchmark
was approved, staff would modify the Real Estate Strategic Plan
to reflect the
new Benchmark. He introduced Mmes. Yalonis and Kendall who followed
with a presentation in support of the recommendation. LACERA's
consultant reported that LACERA currently utilizes the consumer
price index (CPI) +5% net-of-fees, measured over rolling five-year
periods as the benchmark return objective for real estate investments.
This was intended to reflect the investment risk of the asset
class and its ability to hedge inflation. Staff and Townsend
recommend adopting a market-based benchmark, the National Council
of Real Estate Investment Fiduciaries (NCREIF) NCREIF Property
Index (NPI) minus 25 basis points (BS), as the benchmark for
the composite real estate portfolio. The NPI represents the best
index available for use by LACERA as a benchmark and is superior
to the current CPI+5 benchmark. Its use will facilitate higher
quality performance measurement by allowing significant attribution
analysis and risk assessment to be completed. This recommendation
also responds to LACERA's Fiduciary Review of April 2008, Task
7: Risk Management and Internal Controls. The current benchmarks
are computed net of inflation (CPI) net of investment management
fees and cover a rolling five-year period. The proposed recommended
benchmark (NPI-25bps) will be used for LACERA's composite real
estate portfolio and will not impact the individual separate
account managers or commingled fund investments.
The Townsend
Group also reported that the recommended benchmark was realistic
and would serve to control risk in the portfolio, reflecting
a reasonable return expectation which should not lead to assumption
of higher risk in order to achieve the expected returns.
A brief discussion followed with
emphasis on real estate return expectations. A motion to approve
the recommendation was made by Mr. Spare, seconded byMs. Sandoval.
The motion carried with Mr. Pryor abstaining.
- Recommendation as submitted by Christopher J. Wagner,
Senior Investment Officer, Private Equity: That your Board approve
the Private Equity Strategic Plan. (Memo dated January 7 , 2009.)
Mr. Wagner provided a brief overview on the proposed Private
Equity Strategic Plan ("Strategic Plan").
He reported that the Strategic Plan sets forth the strategy for
investing in private equity assets by outlining investment objectives.
Each year LACERA's private equity investment requirements, the
Strategic Plan and the private equity marketplace are reviewed
by staff to determine whether the Strategic Plan is applicable
in the current investment environment. Staff will review the
Strategic Plan annually and LACERA's target allocation to the
various sub-asset classes of private equity and, if needed, make
the necessary revisions for Board approval.
A brief discussion followed on fee reduction
issues. A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr.
Spare, seconded by Ms. Sandoval. The motion carried by unanimous
vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Christopher J. Wagner,
Senior Investment Officer, Private Equity: That your Board adopt
the 2009 Private Equity Investment Plan. (Memo dated January 7,
2009.)
Mr. Wagner provided a brief overview on the proposed Private
Equity Investment Plan ("Plan") and reported that the primary
purpose of the Plan is to establish an appropriate commitment
pace, review and ensure appropriate diversification to private
equity investment strategies (e.g. corporate finance and venture),
and determine the capital allocation between the core portfolio
and discretionary separate accounts. The proposed Plan should
result in LACERA reducing its current allocation to private equity
below the policy range. Mr. Wagner also reported that staff would
continue to closely monitor the private equity allocation and
commitment level, and keep the Board apprised of changes.
A brief discussion followed. A motion
to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by
Ms. Sandoval. The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by June H. Kim, Senior
Investment Officer, Equities, and Shannon O'Connell, Senior Investment
Analyst, Equities: (1) Authorize Staff to modify the mandate for
the enhanced equity portfolio managed by Western Asset Management
Company from a U.S. Equity to a fixed income mandate by:(a) Removing
the S&P 500 Index futures overlay; and (b) Transferring the portfolio's fixed income assets from LACERA's U.S. equity composite to the fixed income composite; and (2) Authorize LACERA's Chief Investment Officer to sign all necessary legal documents to implement the change, subject to review and approval by LACERA's Legal Office. (Memo dated January 7, 2009.)
Mmes. Kim and O'Connell provided an executive summary on the
proposed recommendation and reported that Western Asset Management
Company ("Western")
has managed an enhanced equity portfolio for LACERA since December
2006. Western was asked to by staff to address the strategy's
severe underperformance. Staff continued to provide the Board
with performance and organization updates for this account. Since
May 2008, the Western enhanced equity portfolio has underperformed
its benchmark because of the portfolio's bond holdings. The bonds
have experienced more price declines, mainly due to the condition
of the fixed income market which worsened in September 2008.
Due to the underperformance and the significant lag in the enhanced
equity strategy benchmark, staff is recommending the mandate
be modified to a pure fixed income mandate by removing the equity
futures overlay.
A brief discussion followed. A motion to approve
the recommendation was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by Ms. Sandoval.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Bob Proctor, Director
of Human Resources: (1) That the Board provide the LACERA Chief
Executive Officer (CEO) with a 3% salary increase, effective January
1, 2009, and (2) That the Board adopt an Executive Compensation
Policy and Program that establishes clear and comprehensive executive
compensation guidelines that are in accordance with LACERA's mission,
vision and values. (Memo dated January 7, 2009.)
Mr. Procter provided
a brief overview of the proposed recommendation. The Board commended
Mr. Rademacher on his overall performance. They also expressed
disappointment in that the current economic climate hinders bringing
Mr. Rademacher's salary to the current market level.
A motion to
approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded
by Mr. Spare. The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- VII. REPORTS
- Actuarial Funding Policy
Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive Officer
(Memo dated January 6, 2009.)
Milliman Consultants
Karen I. Steffen, FSA, EA, MAAA, Consulting Actuary
Nick J. Collier, ASA, EA, MAAA, Consulting Actuary
Mr. Rademacher provided a brief overview on the proposed long
term funding policy for retirement benefits. He reported that
LACERA's current actuarial funding policy is a compilation of
Board decisions. The approach is to develop a long-term actuarial
funding policy by using a draft funding policy as a starting
point and discuss key funding topics over a series of meetings.
Mr. Rademacher introduced Karen Steffen and Nick Collier, actuaries
of Milliman, Inc., LACERA's actuary. They followed with a presentation
on the proposed policy. The funding goal establishes the funding
status the Board of Investments would like LACERA to achieve.
The main goal is to provide benefit security for LACERA's members
as well as to achieve and maintain stable employer contributions
that are as low as possible. The policy is also intended to provide
guidance as to when adjustments to LACERA's contributions and
funding for discretionary benefits should be considered by the
Board of Investments. It is meant to assist in establishing a
contribution rate that is relatively stable over the long term,
and provide LACERA members with superior retirement benefit security,
minimizing both the size and volatility of the employer contributions.
The issues to consider are the asset smoothing period, the funding
approach if there is an unfunded actuarial accrued liability
(UAAL).
A brief discussion followed and the Report
was received and filed.
- FIS Group - Fourth Year Review
June Kim, Senior Investment Officer, Equities
Dale Johnson, Senior Investment Analyst, Equities
(Memo dated June 5, 2009.)
FIS Group
Tina Byles Williams, Chief Executive Officer & Chief Investment
Officer
Diallo Johnson, Senior Vice President & Director of Manager
Research
June Kim reported that pursuant to LACERA's Manager Monitoring
and Review Policy, investment managers must appear before the Board
after the second and fourth anniversaries of their initial funding.
FIS began managing a U.S. equity emerging manager fund of funds
mandate for LACERA in September 2004. Ms. Kim introduced the
principals of the FIS Group who followed with a presentation
on the fund's performance.
FIS provided an overview on their
historical background, investment strategy and philosophy.
They are based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, specializing
in identifying and investing with attractive emerging manager
firms. FIS outperformed its benchmark on a relative basis over
all annualized time periods, with a mixed calendar year. Year-to-date
2008 through November. They did underperform by 40 bps net-of-fees,
however, over the same time period, the portfolio slightly
outperformed by 20 bps on a gross-of-fee basis. In addition,
good selection among value stocks, as well as a slight underweight
in the overall portfolio to large cap stocks, contributed positively.
A brief discussion followed with emphasis on transparency concerns.
The Report was
received and filed.
- Operational
Safeguards to Prevent Fraud Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer
(Memo dated January 5, 2009.)
(For information only.)
The memorandum on Operational Safeguards to Prevent Fraud is
for information only and is received and filed.
- Securities Lending Program
- 2008 Annual Review Robert A. Santos, Investment Officer, Fixed
Income (Memo dated January 7, 2009.)
(For information only.)
The
2008 Annual Review on the Securities Lending Program is for information
only and is received and filed.
- GOOD OF THE ORDER
(For discussion purposes only.)
The Board congratulated the newly elected officers and extended a warm
welcome to Mr. Schneider on his reappointment to the Board of Investments.
Mr. Spare reported that he attended the Fiduciary College at Stanford
and indicated that LACERA was well represented at the college with
Mr. Muir, Chief Counsel and Johanna Fontenot, Senior Staff Counsel,
also attending. Mr. Spare recommended the sessions at Fiduciary College
to his colleagues.
Mr. Rademacher congratulated the new officers and
extended a warm welcome to Mr. Schneider on his return to the Investment
Board. He also reminded the Board of the Board Offsite and encouraged
them to attend. He reported that some of the topics to be discussed
are the fiduciary review and policy discussions. He commended Lisa
Mazzocco on preparation of information for said discussions.
Ms. Mazzocco
congratulated the new officers and extended a warm welcome to Mr. Schneider.
Informational Items
1. Memo dated January 6, 2009, from Robert Z. Santos,
Investment Officer, Fixed Income regarding Loomis Sayles.
2. Memo dated January 5, 2009, from Amit Aggarwal, Investment
Officer, Real Estate, regarding Real Estate Independent Fiduciaries
- Search Update.
Green Folder Items
1. Chief Executive Officer's Report dated January 7, 2009.
2. Memo dated January 13, 2009, from Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive
Officer, regarding Board Offsite Agenda.
3. Memo dated January 13,
2009, from Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer, regarding LACERA
total fund performance compared to the Wilshire Associates Pension
Fund Universe.
4. Memo dated January 12, 2009, from Goldman Sachs Asset
Management, L.P.
5. Memo dated January 9, 2009, from June Kim, Senior Investment
Officer, Equities, Shannon O'Connell, Senior Investment Analyst, Equities
regarding Intech Investment Management LLC.
6. Memo dated January 13,
2009, from Beulah S. Canevari, Manager, Financial and Accounting Services
Division regarding Semi-Annual Interest Crediting Rate as of December
31, 2009.
7. Memo dated January 2, 2009, from David L. Muir, Chief
Counsel, regarding Executive Compensation.
8. Copy of Washington Post article dated January 9, 2009, entitled
Troubles in Service Workers' Union May Dim Hopes for Labor.
- ADJOURNMENT
2/18/09
|
|