|
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
BOI MINUTES MARCH 11, 2009 |
|
| |
|
| |
BOARD OF INVESTMENTS MINUTES 3-11-09
PRESENT
- William R. Pryor, Chair
- Herman Santos, Vice Chair
- Diane Sandoval, Secretary
- Paul C. Hudson
- Simon Russin
- Mark J. Saladino
- Michael Schneider
- Leonard Unger
ABSENT
STAFF, ADVISORS, PARTICIPANTS
- Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive Officer
- Robert Hill, Assistant Executive Officer
- Janice Golden, Assistant Executive Officer
- Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer
- John McClelland, CRE, Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate
- Vache Mahseredjian, CFA, Principal Investment Officer
- Christopher J. Wagner, Senior Investment Officer, Private Equity
- June Kim, Senior Investment Officer, Equities
- Trina Sanders, Investment Officer, Real Estate
- Robert Z. Santos, Investment Officer, Fixed Income
- Gerald Flintoft, Investment Officer, Private Equity
- Stuart Mesnik, Senior Investment Analyst
- Shelly P. Tilaye, Senior Investment Analyst, Private Equity
- Dale Johnson, Senior Investment Analyst, Equities
- Shannon O’Connell, Senior Investment Analyst
- David L. Muir, Chief Counsel
- Earl W. Buehner, Senior Staff Counsel
- Johanna M. Fontenot, Senior Staff Counsel
- Michael D. Herrera, Senior Staff Counsel
- Cynthia Lau, Legislative Affairs Officer
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF INVESTMENTS
OF FEBRUARY 11, 2009.
A motion was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by Ms. Sandoval to approve the
Minutes of the regular meeting of the Board of Investments of February
11, 2009.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- PUBLIC COMMENT
Mr. Melvin Trickey, a retiree from the Los Angeles County Probation Department
and a member of the American Federation of State and County Municipal Employees
(AFSME) addressed the Board. He expressed his concern over the current economic
crisis and asked for an update on LACERA’S portfolio status. Mr. Rademacher,
reported that the Fund was well funded and fortunate to have a plan sponsor
and employee groups that historically have done a good job funding the plan.
Coming into the crisis, LACERA was well funded, at nearly 100%. The current
economic crisis has taken a toll on the portfolio, as the funded status was
approximately 95% the last time it was measured on June 30, 2008. Investment
staff is doing an outstanding job to make sure there is liquidity in the portfolio
to meet our monthly payroll obligations.
A brief discussion followed.
- REPORT ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
None
- CONSENT AGENDA
The following agenda items were placed on the consent agenda and unanimously
approved up a motion by Ms. Sandoval, seconded by Mr. Saladino.
The motion carried without objection.
- Recommendation as submitted by Stuart Mesnik, Senior Investment Analyst:
Approve attendance of Board Members to attend the 2009 Wilshire Consulting
Client Conference; and approve reimbursement of all applicable travel costs
associated with attendance at the conference in accordance with the Travel
Policy. (Memo dated March 2, 2009.)
- Recommendation as submitted by June H. Kim, Senior Investment Officer,
Equities: Approve attendance of staff as designated by the Chief Executive
Officer, at the Elkind Emerging Markets Forum; and approve reimbursement
of all travel costs incurred in accordance with LACERA’s Education and
Travel Policy. (Memo dated February 25, 2009.)
- Recommendation as submitted by Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive
Officer: Approve attendance of Board members, and staff as designated by
the Chief Executive Officer, to attend The Labor and Worklilfe Program
at Harvard Law School; and approve reimbursement of all travel costs incurred
in accordance with LACERA’s Education and Travel Policy. (Memo dated March
6, 2009.)
- ACTION ITEMS
- Recommendation as submitted by Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive
Officer: (1) Determine whether to ratify attendance by Board member John
Barger at the CFA Institute’s conference Asset and Risk Allocation 2009;
and (2) If attendance is ratified, approve reimbursement of all conference
fees and travel costs associated with conference attendance according to
LACERA’s Education and Travel Policy. (Memo dated March 4, 2009.) (Placed
on the Agenda at the request of Mr. Barger.)
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded
by Mr. Unger.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
Chair Pryor indicated Action Item C.
would be handled before Item B.
- Recommendation as submitted by Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer:
Adopt the proposed changes to the Investment Policy Statement. (Memo dated
March 4, 2009.)
Ms. Mazzocco provided a brief overview on the proposed changes to the
Investment Policy Statement. She reported that staff and LACERA’s
general consultant, Wilshire Associates reviewed the Investment Policy
Statement and that the Policy Statement outlines the fund’s investment
objectives. As with all living documents, certain modifications are needed
to ensure that it evolves as LACERA’s needs change. Key issues addressed
include the Fund’s investment goals and asset allocation policy,
which also outlines the duties of the Board, staff, investment managers
and consultants. Concerns were raised by Messrs. Russin and Santos relating
to delegation of authority and certain investments strategy concerns. A
brief discussion followed.
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Unger, seconded
by Ms. Sandoval.
The motion carried with Messrs. Russin and Santos voting no.
- Recommendation as submitted by Robert Z. Santos,
Investment Officer, Fixed Income, and Shannon O’Connell, Senior Investment
Analyst: Adopt the Barclays Capital U.S. Universal Index as the new benchmark
for the fixed income composite, effective March 31, 2009. (Memo dated March
4, 2009.)
Mr. Robert Santos provided a brief overview on the proposed recommendation
and reported that staff had previously informed the Board of the intent
to adopt Barclays Capital U.S. Universal Index (“Universal”)
as the new benchmark for LACERA’s fixed income composite. Universal
is a comprehensive, dollar-denominated fixed income benchmark which includes
all components of the Barclays capital aggregate index (Aggregate) as well
as non-Aggregate sectors such as high yield and emerging market debt. Universal
offers the broadest measure of the U.S. fixed income market. Staff views
it as the most appropriate benchmark to gauge the risk-adjusted performance
of LACERA’s fixed income composite. Rather than adjusting the benchmark
each time a change is made to the high yield allocation, LACERA should
adopt a benchmark that includes a high yield component and is more inclusive
of other sectors in the U.S. bond market. Universal also supports the Board’s
recent approval of a new fixed income structure (Core, Core Plus, and Opportunistic)
and as part of the structure implementation, LACERA’s fixed income
managers will invest across a larger breadth of fixed income securities
in order to improve the portfolio’s risk-adjusted returns. Consequently,
the composite’s benchmark should reflect the broadest available set
of U.S. fixed income investment opportunities. The adoption of Universal
as LACERA’s benchmark will improve Staff’s ability to measure
market risk and return while remaining consistent with LACERA’s approach
to benchmarking the domestic equity portfolio. A brief discussion followed
on fixed income issues.
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Ms. Sandoval, seconded
by Mr. Unger.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
Having acted on Item C, Chair Pryor indicated the Board would return to
the regular order of business.
- Recommendation as submitted by June Kim, Senior Investment Officer,
Equities, and Shannon O’Connell, Senior Investment Analyst: Authorize Staff
to terminate American Century Investment Management’s small capitalization
core mandate. (Memo dated March 3, 2009.)
Ms. Kim provided a brief overview on the proposed termination of American
Century Investment Management (“American”). She reported that American
presented before the Board on September 24, 2008, to address its continue
and substantial underperformance. American’s performance has not improved
since its September 2008 presentation. Instead, American continued to generate
significant underperformance through January 2009,while most of LACERA’s
quantitative managers demonstrated stability during the same volatile period;
in fact some managers contributed positive relative returns to the U.S.
equity composite. A brief discussion followed on with emphasis on transition
costs.
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Russin, seconded
by Mr. Saladino.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by David L. Muir, Chief Counsel: Approve
the attached ballot insert entitled “POWERS AND DUTIES OF INVESTMENTS BOARD
MEMBERS” to be included with the ballot materials for the election of the
Third Member of the Board of Investments. (Memo dated February 24, 2009.)
Ms. Fontenot provided a brief overview of the proposed Powers and Duties
of Investments Board Members to be included with the ballot materials for
the election of the Third Member of the Board of Investments. A discussion
followed during which it was suggested that the document include the Board’s
responsibilities regarding security litigation issues.
A motion was made by Mr. Schneider, seconded by Ms. Sandoval to Approve
the Powers and Duties of Invest-ments Board Members as amended to include
a reference to the Board’s responsibilities regarding securities litigation.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Cynthia Lau, Legislative Affairs Officer:
That your Board adopt a “Watch” position on HR 710. (Memo dated February
26, 2009.)
HR 710
Ms. Lau reported that HR 710 would provide a guaranteed investment opportunity
for state and local pension plans. The bill would encourage state and local
retirement plan investment in TARP approved financial institutions. In
return for investing in a class of preferred stock, the retirement plans
would receive an 8.5% guaranteed rate of return as well as a guarantee
of principal. The goal is to provide an infusion of non U.S. government
capital into the banking system, which would create additional capital
for consumer loans. The investments would be a guarantee directly by the
U.S.Treasury rather than a deposit guarantee through the FDIC. Another
goal of the bill is to provide a guaranteed investment opportunity for
state and local plans which have been hard hit by the capital markets.
A detailed analysis of this proposal is not yet available, therefore, staff
recommends that LACERA continue to monitor this bill.
A motion was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded by Ms. Sandoval to adopt a “Watch” position
on HR 710.
The motion carried with Mr. Hudson abstaining. (Mr. Hudson is the President
and Chief Executive Officer of Broadway Federal Bank, which was the recipient
of TARP funds.)
- Recommendation as submitted by Cynthia Lau, Legislative Affairs Officer:
That your Board adopt a “Watch” position on AB 137. (Memo dated February
23, 2009.)
AB 137
Ms. Lau reported that the Ralph M. Brown Act requires that all meetings
of a legislative body of a local agency be open and public and all persons
be permitted to attend unless a closed session is authorized. In defining
a legislative body for this purpose, the act excludes ad hoc advisory committees
composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than
a quorum of the legislative body. AB 137 would amend Government Code Section
54952 to require that ad hoc advisory committees that are less than a quorum
hold their meetings in public if the committee has been established for
more than two years. LACERA has occasionally appointed ad hoc committees
to review specific issues in closed session. It is not anticipated that
such committees would last longer than two years. However, if an advisory
or ad hoc committee lasted longer than two years, this bill would require
such committee meetings to be conducted in open session after the two-year
mark.
A motion was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded by Ms. Sandoval, to take a “watch” position
on AB 137.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- VI. REPORTS
- Implementation of New Fixed Income Structure Vache Mahseredjian,
Principal Investment Officer (Memo dated March 1, 2009.) (For information
only.)
The Report is for information only and was received and filed.
- Annual Report on Securities Litigation Michael D. Herrera, Senior
Staff Counsel (Memo dated February 20, 2009.) (For information only.)
The Report is for information only and was received and filed.
- Assembly Concurrent Resolution 4 Cynthia Lau, Legislative Affairs
Officer (Memo dated February 23, 2009.) (For information only.)
The Resolution is for information only and was received and filed.
- Update on Corporate Governance Items Dale Johnson, Senior Investment
Analyst – Equities (For information only.)
The Update on Corporate Governance Items is for information only and was
received and filed.
- GOOD OF THE ORDER (For discussion purposes only.)
Mr. Russin reported on his attendance at the Pacific Pension Institute and
the Corporate Governance Roundup indicating that it was excellent. He commended
Mr. Pryor on hosting the Roundup.
Ms. Sandoval reported that the RREEF Client Conference was also a very informative
session.
Mr. Hudson asked that Wilshire Consultants provide a report for the Board
on concerns relating to Westridge Capital Management.
Green Folder Items
- Chief Executive Officer’s Report
- Memo dated March 10, 2009, from Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment
Officer, regarding Wilshire Associates News Article.
- Memo dated February 23, 2009, from Cynthia Lau, Legislative Affairs
Officer regarding Assembly Concurrent Resolution 4.
- Copy of Voice of San Diego article dated March 2, 2009, from David
L. Muir, Chief Counsel, entitled PensionBonds Still on San Diego’s Radar
Screen.
- Copy of Berman DeValerio Monitor, dated Winter 2009, from David
L. Muir, Chief Counsel entitled Proposed Bill Would Let Public Funds
Invest in Troubled Banks.
- Copy of Voice of San Diego article dated March 5, 2009, from David
L. Muir, Chief Counsel, entitled County Pension Investment Guru Resigns.
- Copy of San Diego County Employees Retirement Association new release
dated February 26, 2009, from David L. Muir, Chief Counsel, regarding
SDCERA Issues Statement Regarding WG Trading. 8. Copy of Voice of San
Diego article dated March 3, 2009, from David L. Muir, Chief Counsel,
entitled Hedge Fund Woes Gore San Diego County Again.
- ADJOURNMENT
5/19/09
|
|