|
|
| |
About LACERA Homepage > LACERA Boards > 2009 Board of Investments > BOI Minutes 8-12-09 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
BOI MINUTES AUGUST 12, 2009 |
|
| |
|
| |
BOARD OF INVESTMENTS MINUTES 8-12-09
PRESENT
- William R. Pryor, Chair
- Herman Santos, Vice Chair
- Diane Sandoval, Secretary
- Paul C. Hudson
- Simon Russin
- Mark J. Saladino
- Michael Schneider
- Leonard Unger
ABSENT
STAFF, ADVISORS, PARTICIPANTS
- Robert Hill, Assistant Executive Officer
- Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer
- John McClelland, CRE, Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate
- Vache Mahseredjian, CFA, Principal Investment Officer
- Christopher J. Wagner, Senior Investment Officer, Private Equity
- June Kim, Senior Investment Officer, Equities
- Robert Z. Santos, Investment Officer, Fixed Income
- Shannon O’Connell, Senior Investment Analyst
- Dale Johnson, Senior Investment Analyst, Equities
- Robb Van Der Volgen, Chief Counsel
- Michael D. Herrera, Senior Staff Counsel
- Christine Roseland, Staff Counsel
- Cynthia Lau, Legislative Affairs Officer
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE BOARD OF INVESTMENTS
OF JUNE 10, 2009.
A motion was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded by Mr. Unger, to approve
the Minutes of the meeting of the Board of Investments of June 10, 2009.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE BOARD OF INVESTMENTS
OF JULY 8, 2009.
A motion was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by Ms. Sandoval, to approve the
Minutes of the meeting of the Board of Investment of July 8, 2009.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- PUBLIC COMMENT
None.
- REPORT ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
None.
- REPORTS
- Manager Reviews – Fixed Income Robert Z. Santos, Investment Officer,
(Memo dated July 28, 2009.)
LM Capital Management
Luis Maizel, Co-Founder and Senior Managing Director
John Chalker, Co-Founder and Managing Director
Richard Deary, Director Business Development
Robert Santos gave a brief overview on the performance of LM Capital Management
(LM Capital) and reported that pursuant to LACERA’s Manager Monitoring
and Review Policy, investment managers must conduct a formal portfolio
review when their one-year rolling excess returns are outside pre-determined
performance bands for three consecutive quarters. He introduced the principals,
Messrs. Luis Maizel, John Chalker, and Richard Deary who gave a presentation
on LM Capital’s historical background, investment process and strategy.
LM Capital is based in San Diego, California and they have managed a core-plus
fixed income mandate for LACERA since January 2002. They have been a leading
proponent of the Core Plus strategy since the firm’s inception in 1989.
LM Capital utilizes a global macro-economic approach to their investing
strategy. LM Capital believes in a global approach to managing fixed income
securities, based upon a fundamental analysis of global macro-economic
factors of the G-7 which consists of (the world’s seven largest industrial
market economies, being the United States, Japan, Germany, France, United
Kingdom, Italy, Canada and other selected countries to determine the most
attractive fixed income markets.
Their investment strategy group includes two foreign nationals, which
enables them to gain a better understanding of the business culture in
foreign markets and to benefit from the association with the senior management
of many foreign companies. Another key aspect of LM Capital’s investment
process is their concentrated approach to portfolio construction. This
approach allows the team to focus on the portfolio’s securities and invest
only in its best investment ideas As of June 30, 2009, LM Capital underperformed
its benchmark by 3 and 73 bps annualized, net-of-fees, for one and two
year periods respectively. Since inception, the portfolio has outperformed
the benchmark by nearly 43 bps, annualized, net of fees. This portfolio
has rebounded since its underperformance ending on March 31, 2009. A brief
discussion followed and the Report was received and filed.
- Manager Reviews – Fixed Income Shannon O’Connell, Senior Investment
Analyst, Fixed Income (Memo dated July 30, 2009.)
BlackRock, Inc.
Diane E. Parish, Managing Director
Andrew J. Phillips, Managing Director
Robert Santos presented a brief overview on the performance of BlackRock,
Inc. (BlackRock) and reported that pursuant to LACERA’s Manager Monitoring
and Review Policy, investment managers must conduct formal presentations
when their one-year rolling excess returns are outside pre-determined performance
bands for three consecutive quarters. This is BlackRock’s first presentation
for underperformance since they were hired by LACERA in March of 1997.
The principals of BlackRock, Diane Parish and Andrew Phillips, followed
with a presentation on BlackRock’s historical background, investment strategy
and the portfolio’s performance.
BlackRock began managing a core fixed income mandate for LACERA in March
1997.
Ms. Parish and Mr. Phillips reported that Barclays PLC accepted BlackRock’s
offer to purchase Barclays Global Investors (BGI). The combined firm will
be renamed BlackRock Global Investors. BGI’s fixed income assets are largely
passive and thus are complementary to BlackRock’s active fixed income management
business. With little overlap between the two businesses, BlackRock does
not expect to make significant changes to the core bond investment team
or process as a result of the BGI acquisition. The deal is expected to
close in the fourth quarter of 2009.
BlackRock’s investment process utilizes a risk-controlled, relative value,
sector rotation and security selection approach to the management of core
bond portfolios. This investment process requires collaboration between
their portfolio and investment teams. These teams are responsible for research,
bottom-up idea generation, ongoing monitoring of all positions, and trade
execution. Research analysts are part of the Investment Teams and are responsible
fore credit and macroeconomic research, implementing the investment strategy
to determine security selection, timing, and execution, in accordance with
the clients’ investment objectives and guidelines.
BlackRock’s core fixed income portfolio performance as of June 30, 2009,
(on a gross-and net-of-fee basis) underperformed the BC Aggregate by 193,
103, and 47 bps (annualized and net of fees) on a one, three, and five
year basis respectively. BlackRock consistently outperformed the benchmark
in ten of the twelve years that they managed core fixed income assets for
LACERA.
In 2006, they underperformed by only 2 bps and in 2008 they lagged the
benchmark. The period from July 2007 to March 2009 was challenging for
most fixed income managers, and in particular those that overweighted non-Treasury
sectors. Moreover, the corporate, asset-backed and mortgage-backed sectors
experienced their worst performance on record. In the second quarter of
2009, non-treasury sectors rebounded strongly, which benefited managers
that continued to hold overweight positions in high quality non-Treasury
securities. BlackRock’s performance reflects the very difficult period
in the bond market. As commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) and
non-agency residential mortgage-backed securities (non-agency RMBS) performed
extremely poorly during the credit crisis, BlackRock’s portfolio underperformed
due to its overweight positions in these securities. However, their continued
overweight in CMBS and non-agency RMBS through the end of the second quarter
led the portfolio to a solid second quarter rebound, where they outperformed
the benchmark by 239 bps. Additionally, BlackRock’s overweight position
in U.S. credit and their non-dollar exposure also contributed to their
strong second quarter performance. A brief discussion followed and the
Report was received and filed.
- Performance Review as of June 30, 2009
Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer
Wilshire Associates Incorporated
William Bensur, CFA, Managing Director
Ms. Mazzocco, Ms. Kim and Mr. Mahseredjian provided an executive summary
on the fund’s performance for the second quarter 2009. They reported that
LACERA’s Total Fund returned 10.1%, but lagged its Policy Benchmark return
of 11.4%. The underperformance of 130 basis points (bps) was mainly due
to weight differences between components of the actual asset allocation
and the target asset allocation. The Fund was underweight public equities
and commodities (the quarter’s best performing asset classes) and overweight
private equity and real estate (the worst performers). The Domestic Equity
composite rose 16.6% and slightly trailed its benchmark by 20bps as most
of the active managers underperformed their respective benchmarks; however
the International Equity composite returned 28.7% and was the best performing
asset class for the quarter. The composite beat its benchmark by 10 bps,
helped by strong relative results from the active regional investment managers.
The fixed Income composite surpassed the benchmark by 430 bps for the quarter.
This was the result of the relative outperformance of all core and core
plus managers.
The Real Estate portfolio declined 8.2% versus its benchmark return of
-7.6%, an underperformance of 60 bps.
LACERA’s Private Equity portfolio returned -5.3% and underperformed its
benchmark return of 0.7% by 600 bps. The private equity benchmark uses
a rolling ten-year return of the Russell 3000 Index.
A brief discussion followed on the current domestic and international
market environment and the Report was received and filed.
June Kim introduced Bill Benzur of Wilshire Associates, LACERA’s Consultant,
who followed with an Investment Review and Capital Market Review for the
period ending June 30, 2009, with emphasis on US Equity, Non-US Equity
and Fixed Income. A brief discussion followed with emphasis on skill analysis,
risk management and risk control. The Board commended staff and Mr. Benzur
on the Reports, which were received and filed.
- Trust Universe Comparison Services (TUCS) Data Lisa Mazzocco, Chief
Investment Officer (For information only.)
The Trust Universe Comparison Services (TUCS) Data is for information
only and was received and filed.
- Real Estate Performance Measurement Quarter Ended March 31, 2009
John McClelland, Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate (Memo dated
August 3, 2009.) (For information only.)
The Townsend Group
Micolyn Yalonis, Principal
The Real Estate Performance Measurement Report is for information only
and is received and filed.
- EXECUTIVE SESSION
- CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS (Government Code Section 54957.6)
Agency designated representatives:
Robert Hill, Assistant Executive Officer
Robert Proctor, Director of Human Resources
John Nogales, Senior Human Resources Analyst
Sharon Norton, Senior Human Resources Analyst
Robb Van Der Volgen, Chief Counsel
Employee organization:
Service Employees International Union (SEIU), Local 721
The Board met in Executive Session pursuant to Government Code Section
54957.6 to discuss labor negotiations with Service Employees International
Union (SEIU), Local 721. The Board reconvened in open session, at which
time Mr. Hill indicated that there was nothing to report at this time.
- GOOD OF THE ORDER
(For discussion purposes only.)
The Board extended a warm welcome to LACERA’s new Chief Counsel, Robb Van
Del Volgen, who comes from the California Department of Corporations, and has
a long history with CalSTRS.
Mr. Santos stated he received a letter from the Board of Supervisors asking
that investments in Iran-related securities be addressed and respectfully requests
that staff place this item on the Agenda for the October Investment Board meeting,
unless the County ask that it be handled sooner. Staff has agreed to handle
this matter. The Board extended their congratulations to Mr. Russin for winning
re-election and will continue to serve on the Board of Retirement, representing
the General Members.
Informational Items
- Memo dated July 24, 2009, from Dale Johnson, Senior Investment
Analyst regarding Corporate Governance Quarterly Review Volume 5, Issue
#2: April 1, 2009 – June 30, 2009.
- Memo dated July 30, 2009, from John McCelland, Principal Investment
Officer, Real Estate, regarding Single Family Home Building Program,
Revised Performance Measurement methodology.
Green Folder Items
- Chief Executive Officer’s Report.
- Memo dated August 11, 2009 from Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment
Officer, regarding Trust Universe Comparison Service (TUCS) Data.
- Memo dated August 10, 2009, from Nai-len Ishikawa, Acting Manager,
Financial and Accounting Services Division regarding the Semi-Annual
Interest Crediting Rate as of June 30, 2009 (Unaudited).
- Memo dated August 6, 2009, from Michael D. Herrera, Senior Staff
Counsel, regarding LACERA v. Motorola, Inc., Scientific-Atlanta, et al.,
Case No. 04 Civ 10252 (S.D.N.Y.)
- ADJOURNMENT
10/19/09
|
|