| |
BOARD OF INVESTMENTS MINUTES 9-9-09
PRESENT
- Simon S. Russin, Chair Pro Tem
- John M. Barger
- Mark J. Saladino
- Michael Schneider
- Leonard Unger
ABSENT
- William Pryor, Chair
- Herman Santos, Vice Chair
- Diane Sandoval, Secretary
- Paul C. Hudson
STAFF, ADVISORS, PARTICIPANTS
- Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive Officer
- Robert Hill, Assistant Executive Officer
- Janice Golden, Assistant Executive Officer
- Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer
- John McClelland, CRE, Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate
- Vache Mahseredjian, CFA, Principal Investment Officer
- Christopher J. Wagner, Senior Investment Officer, Private Equity
- June Kim, Senior Investment Officer, Equities
- Trina Sanders, Investment Officer, Real Estate
- Robert Z. Santos, Investment Officer, Fixed Income
- Gerald Flintoft, Investment Officer, Private Equity
- Stuart Mesnik, Senior Investment Analyst
- Shelly P. Tilaye, Senior Investment Analyst, Private Equity
- Shannon O’Connell, Senior Investment Analyst
- Dale Johnson, Senior Investment Analyst, Equities
- Robb Van Der Volgen, Chief Counsel
- Earl W. Buehner, Senior Staff Counsel
- Johanna M. Fontenot, Senior Staff Counsel
- Michael D. Herrera, Senior Staff Counsel
- Cynthia Lau, Legislative Affairs Officer
Mr. Rademacher reported that the officers of the Board of Investments would not
be in attendance at today’s meeting and a chair pro tem would have to be elected,
as provided in Robert’s Rules of Order. Therefore the following motion was made:
On a motion made by Mr. Schneider, seconded by Mr. Unger the Board unanimously
nominated Mr. Russin as Chair Pro Tem.
- APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
- A. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE BOARD OF INVESTMENTS
OF AUGUST 12, 2009.
A motion to was made by Mr. Unger, seconded by Mr. Saladino, to approve
the Minutes of the meeting of the Board of Investments of August 12, 2009.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- PUBLIC COMMENT
None.
- REPORT ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
None.
- IV. ACTION ITEMS
- Recommendation as submitted by Gregg Rademacher, Chief Executive
Officer: That your Board approve attendance of Board members and staff
as designated by the Chief Executive Officer, at the Relational Investors
Client Conference and approve reimbursement of all travel costs incurred
in accordance with LACERA’s Education and Travel Policy. (Memo dated September
2, 2009.) (Placed on the Agenda at the request of Ms. Sandoval.)
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded
by Mr. Unger.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by John D. McClelland, Principal Investment
Officer, Real Estate and Earl W. Buehner, Senior Staff Counsel: (1) Approve
attendance of Board members, and staff as designated by the Chief Executive
Officer, at INVESCO Real Estate’s 6th Annual Client Conference on November
3-5, 2009, at the Lodge at Torrey Pines in La Jolla, California; (2) Approve
payment to INVESCO for its actual costs of providing meals and associated
programs to LACERA’s representatives attending the conference; and (3)
Approve reimbursement of all other costs associated with conference attendance
in accordance with LACERA’s Education and Travel Policy. (Memo dated August
25, 2009.)
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Schneider, seconded
by Mr. Unger.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer:
Reschedule the Wednesday, November 11, 2009, Board of Investments meeting
to Wednesday, November 18, 2009. (Memo dated August 26, 2009.)
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Unger, seconded
by Mr. Saladino.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by John McClelland, CRE, Principal Investment
Officer, Real Estate: Adopt the 2009-2010 Real Estate Investment Plan as
presented. (Memo dated September 1, 2009.)
Mr. McClelland provided a brief overview of the 2009-2010 Real Estate
Investment Plan. He reported that staff developed the Real Estate Investment
Plan (the “Plan”) to guide the equity real estate investment activities
of the Fund during the 2009-2010 fiscal year. If approved and fully implemented
the Plan is projected to result in the Fund reducing its current allocation
to real estate from 10.2% to 9.6%, well within the Policy range of 7% to
15%. Mr. McClelland also reported that new investment commitments are expected
to be minimal since the Fund is beginning the year in an over-allocated
state. A portion of the existing commitments are expected to be drawn during
the year.
The real estate investment environment remains extremely challenging.
Rental rates have dropped, capitalization rates have increased, and debt
availability has declined substantially.
A couple of key points on the proposed Plan are: Separate account managers,
responsible for over 90% of the portfolio investments, will manage existing
assets and very selectively sell properties; and no capital is being made
available for new investment by these managers as LACERA begins the new
fiscal year. The Plan will also allow for LACERA to opportunistically take
advantage of compelling opportunities if/as they arise. Also, new commingled
fund investment opportunities will not be considered until the over-allocated
condition is remedied. A brief discussion followed.
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded
by Mr. Barger.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by John D. McClelland, Principal Investment
Officer, Real Estate: Adopt the revised Real Estate Strategic Plan as presented.
(Memo dated August 26, 2009.)
Mr. McClelland provided an executive summary on the proposed Strategic
Plan. A brief discussion followed on risk and allocation concerns.
A motion was made by Mr. Schneider, seconded by Mr. Unger to Adopt the
revised Real Estate Strategic Plan as presented.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Lisa Mazzocco, Chief Investment Officer,
and June Kim, Senior Investment Officer, Equities: Provide Staff with direction
regarding LACERA’s holding companies identified as having operations or
investments in Iran. (Memo dated September 1, 2009.) Ms. Kim
reported that the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors met at their
regular meeting on July 21, 2009, during which they approved a motion requesting
that LACERA “divest from those companies that are liable to U.S. Government
sanctions by virtue of their investments in the Iranian energy sector”.
Ms. Kim stated that LACERA has no holdings in any Iranian companies or
any companies that are domiciled in Iran. Any exposure would be from holdings
in global companies, typically oil, construction, or energy companies that
may have a small portion of their operations in Iran. Ms. Kim pointed out
for the record that there was a typo on page 6 of the memo dated September
1, 2009, as follows: The divestment-related costs of $16.97 million is
incorrect; the correct amount is $18.9 million.
Ms. Kim also reported, when dealing with these type of divestment issues,
in the past the Board has generally opted to adopt a policy (such as with
tobacco and Sudan) directing the investment managers to choose (in this
case) the Iran-free security when choosing between two securities having
the same investment goals concerning risk, return and diversification.
A brief discussion on issues relating to proposed legislation.
Mr. Saladino made a motion, seconded by Mr. Unger to adopt option 4 in
staff’s memorandum (to adopt a policy similar to LACERA’s existing Tobacco
and Sudan Policies) with further instruction to staff to send a letter
to the Board of Supervisors informing them that State legislation protecting
LACERA Board members and staff from claims of breach of fiduciary, similar
to AB 221, would give LACERA more flexibility regarding divestment. The
motion carried by unanimous vote.
Mr. Rademacher agreed to respond to the letter from the Board of Supervisors
addressing their divestment concerns.
- Recommendation as submitted by Earl W. Buehner, Senior Staff Counsel:
Consent to the assignment of the Investment Management Agreement from PENN
Capital Management Company, Inc. a New Jersey corporation, to PENN Capital
Management Company, Inc., a Delaware corporation, and authorize staff to
execute such consents and other documents to effect the assignment as reviewed
and approved by the LACERA Legal Office. (Memo dated August 25, 2009.)
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Unger, seconded
by Mr. Saladino.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- Recommendation as submitted by Michael D. Herrera, Senior Staff
Counsel: That your Board authorize the Legal Office to retain the Grant & Eisenhofer
law firm on a pro bono basis to file an amicus curiae brief on behalf of
LACERA in Merck & Co. Inc. v. Reynolds. (Memo dated August 31, 2009.)
Mr. Van Der Volgen on behalf of Mr. Herrera, provided a brief summary
on the retention of the Grant & Eisenhofer law firm. This amicus brief
filing would be on a pro bono basis and would be on behalf of LACERA. A
brief discussion followed.
A motion to approve the recommendation was made by Mr. Saladino, seconded
by Mr. Schneider.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
- REPORTS
- Manager Review – Fixed Income Robert Z. Santos, Investment Officer,
(Memo dated August 31, 2009.)
Post Advisory Group
Larry Post, Vice Chairman
Allen Schweitzer, Chief Investment Officer
Ralph Canada, Managing Director, Marketing
Robert Santos provided an executive summary on Post Advisory Group’s (Post)
performance. He reported that LACERA’s Manager Monitoring and Review Policy
(the Policy) stipulates that investment managers must conduct formal presentations
when their one-year rolling excess returns are outside pre-determined performance
bands for three consecutive quarters. (The performance band for high yield
mandates is -50 basis points to +250 basis points.) Post is presenting
due to their strong performance results during the 18-month period ending
March 2009. Mr. Santos introduced Messrs. Larry Post, Allen Schweitzer
and Ralph Canada, who gave a presentation on the fund’s historical background,
investment process and performance.
Post is based in Los Angeles, California and has $8.8 Billion assets under
management, with approximately $5.7 billion in their Traditional High Yield
Fixed Income (High Yield) strategy as of July 31, 2009. They began managing
a high yield fixed income mandate for LACERA in January 2002 as part of
LACERA’s fixed income Emerging Manager Program, and in March of 2003, Post
was awarded a full high yield mandate.
Post manages high yield portfolios based on a bottom-up process that utilizes
a proprietary model for all of their investment decisions. The model enables
Post to compare, in a consistent manner, different types of securities
from diverse companies and industries, as well as estimate probable downside
risk. Their philosophy emphasizes downside protection with a primary concentration
on controlling credit risk, default risk and liquidity risk. There are
no changes to the investment strategy, the firm’s decision-making process
or the team responsible for managing LACERA’s portfolio.
As of July 31, 2009, Post’s portfolio trailed the BC High Yield Ba/B Index
by 4.7% and 1.4%, for calendar year-to-date and one-year periods, respectively,
net-of-fees. However, since the account’s inception, the portfolio has
out-performed the benchmark by 62 bps annualized, net of fees. Post’s strategy,
which focuses on the upper and middle tiers of the high yield market, outperformed
their Index by 236 and 385 bps, gross-of-fees, in 2007 and 2008, respectively.
This outperformance occurred in the midst of the worst credit crisis since
the Depression. This portfolio has performed as expected: outperforming
in 2007-2008, underperforming in the 2nd quarter of 2009. Post believes
over the long term, their investment approach will outperform the benchmark.
They are cautiously optimistic and the fund’s outperformance since-inception
of 62 bps supports this view. A brief discussion followed and the Report
was received and filed.
- EXECUTIVE SESSION
- A. Public Employee Performance Evaluation (Government Code Section
54957)
Title: Chief Investment Officer
In the matter of a Public Employee Performance Evaluation, the Board met
in Executive Session pursuant to Government Code Section 54957, for the
Chief Investment Officer and there was nothing to report at this time.
- GOOD OF THE ORDER
(For discussion purposes only.)
Mr. Schneider reported that the Wall Street Journal had an article relating
to attorney’s fees and hourly rate content being reviewed by clients. He asked
that the Legal Office explore outside counsel fees and to ensure they are in
line with LACERA’s guidelines.
Mr. Barger asked that LACERA’s Actuary comment on an article they wrote relating
to the world’s economic evolution. (For discussion purposes only.)
Mr. Rademacher congratulated and thanked Mr. Russin for winning this morning’s
election and stepping in as Chair pro tem. Mr. Rademacher also reported on
a letter he received from the Interim Executive Director at SACRS expressing
his concern relating to an elected trustee’s role on a retirement board being
their primary duty, in relation to their other county employment. Mr. Rademacher
agreed to respond to this letter.
The Board and Ms. Mazzocco extended their good wishes to Stuart Mesnik who
is retiring from the Investment Office on September 30, 2009.
Informational Items
- Memo dated September 2, 2009, from John D. McClelland, Principal Investment Officer, Real Estate, regarding Renovation Update, St. Regis Princeville Resort.
- Memo dated August 27, 2009, from Trina L. Sanders, Investment Officer, Real Estate, regarding Real Estate Appraisal Results. 3. Memo dated September 2, 2009, from Robert Z. Santos, Investment Officer, Fixed Income, regarding Wachovia Global Securities Lending.
Green Folder Items
- Chief Executive Officer’s Report.
- Copy of letter dated September 1, 2009, from Robert Palmer, SACRS Interim Executive Director.
- ADJOURNMENT
10/19/09
|